Land Exchange Deeds with ‘Nil Consideration’: ITAT Clarifies Section 43CA Applicability

Land Exchange Deeds with ‘Nil Consideration’: ITAT Clarifies Section 43CA Applicability

Section 43CA of the Act is a deeming provision aimed at under-reported consideration. It should not apply merely because a deed says “Nil Consideration”. Where land is exchanged for land of equivalent extent and value under a pre-existing agreement, substance should prevail over statutory provisions.

The result rested on documentation: the MOU, matching schedules of land parcels transferred and received, and uniform values across the deeds. Taxpayers in similar arrangements should record the exchange in writing before executing the deeds and keep a reconciliation of land parcels transferred and received to avoid tax liability in any future litigations.